PZ Myers on the evolution of eyes

Seed magazine has a new article by evolutionary biologist PZ Myers on the deep common ancestry of different kinds of eyes in some cases. The article is “Eyeing the Evolutionary Past.” Prof. Myers points out that

Jellyfish eyes“While eyes are common in larger animal species, about a third of all animal phyla lack eyes altogether; sea urchins do not bother with them, nor do many worms. Another third have eyes that look rudimentary to us; spots and patches and pits that can sense whether it’s night or day or whether a shadow is passing overhead, but that do not form any kind of image. The final third have true image-forming eyes that can capture a picture of what’s going on around them and pass that on to some kind of brain or nerve net. The phyla that have true eyes are a diverse subset of the multicellular animals, including jellyfish and sea anemones, molluscs, annelid worms, onychophora (velvet worms), arthropods, and us chordates, which is a strange distribution. It’s as if eyes popped up in scattered lineages interspersed with groups that lack them. For a long time, one of the hypotheses to explain all these eyes was that they evolved independently, multiple times within the animal kingdom.”

It’s a little creepy to me to think of sea urchins crawling on the ocean floor or jellyfish pulsing through the deeps without eyes to guide them. I know that some jellyfish have eyes. Others seem to lack them. But that last statement suggests that Prof. Myers is about to reveal a contrary discovery. First he explains a very fundamental difference between two kinds of eyes: ciliary and rhabdomeric. Read the article for a new insight into eyes and evolution.


One Response to “PZ Myers on the evolution of eyes”

  1. Biology Talks: PZ Myers and Carl Zimmer « a clever blog Says:

    […] Coincidentally, PZ Myers was in the audience of the Carl Zimmer talk.  I’m assuming the reason he wasn’t asked to leave was because security didn’t spot him.  He also assured me that he was not in town to egg the Discovery Institute.  He seemed to be a fairly mellow guy, which you might not have realized if you read his blog.  I later bumped into him at the Seattle Skeptics dinner where he was giving a presentation on the evolution of eyes.  His presentation was informative and amusing.  However, the material was rather dense for a nonbiologist — it would be great if he reworked his presentation into a small book. It also looks like someone has written up a blog about a similar article by PZ Myers. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: